Rekeying vs Replacing Locks

How to Make the Right Choice For Your Home 

rekeying vs replacing locks

When you need to upgrade the security of your existing locks, you’re faced with 2 options, either rekey or replace. While both options offer their benefits, the choice ultimately depends on your specific security needs and budget. Read on to see which option could work best for your situation to make an informed decision.

What is Rekeying?

Rekeying is the process of modifying the existing lock’s mechanism to only work with a new key. Rekeying is done by replacing the existing lock pins with new ones that match a different key.

Pros and Cons of Rekeying Your Locks

Cost-effective compared to replacing locks May not be possible for some types of locks
Quick process that can be completed in minutes Requires the services of a professional locksmith
Provides an extra layer of security by preventing unauthorized access The new key may not match your existing key design
Avoids the need to replace your existing locks and hardware May not address underlying issues with the lock mechanism
Allows you to maintain control over who has access to your home If you lose the new keys, you will need to rekey again or replace the locks


What is Involved in Replacing New Locks?

Replacing locks involves removing the old lock mechanism and installing a new one. This procedure usually necessitates the removal and replacement of old hardware, including the lock and any other components, such as the strike plate or latch. It is usually a more expensive and time-consuming process than rekeying but may be necessary if the old lock is destroyed or compromised.

Pros and Cons of Installing New Locks

Provides the highest level of security More expensive than rekeying
Allows for customization of lock features and design Requires more time to install than rekeying
Addresses underlying issues with the lock mechanism May require additional hardware updates
May increase the value of your property Requires the services of a professional locksmith
Can be necessary if the existing lock is damaged or compromised New keys may need to be distributed to all parties


How to Choose Between Rekeying and Installing New Locks

Choosing between rekeying or installing new locks to improve the security of your home can be a conflicting decision. Before deciding, consider your budget, security preferences, the age of your current locks, available time, and any access control requirements you may have.

Rekeying vs Installing New Locks Comparison

RekeyingInstalling New Locks
Cost-effective More expensive
Quick process Requires more time
Added layer of security Highest level of security
Maintains existing hardware Allows new lock hardware and features to be installed
May not address underlying issues Addresses underlying issues with the lock mechanism
Limited access control Provides more access control options


When to Rekey Your Locks

If you've recently moved into a new home, lost your keys, or experienced a security breach, rekeying your locks is a good idea. It's also a good idea if you need to deny entry to certain people or just want to increase the general security of your property.

Situations Where Rekeying is Recommended


When to Change Your Locks

If your locks are damaged or compromised, like after a break-in or attempted break-in, you should replace them. Any lock that is old, worn out, or not working properly should also be replaced. By replacing your locks, you have the opportunity to add higher security locks such as deadbolts.

Situations Where Changing Locks is Recommended


Suncoast Locksmith - Your Local Locksmith for St. Petersburg

At Suncoast Locksmith, we offer both lock rekeying and lock replacement services. We’ll help you decide between rekeying your existing locks or if it’s time to upgrade to new ones. When you call us, you’ll be treated to prompt, efficient service. And we’ll even identify ways to save you money along the way. Contact us for fast service today.

Back To Blog